This episode: Catfish, Season 1, Eps. 1-4, 7-8, 13. Watch it on Hulu.
Next episode: Doomsday Preppers, Season 3, Eps. 1-5, 9. Watch it on Hulu.
This month the show returns to its MTV stomping grounds for one of their most successful and popular shows of recent vintage – which is apparently responsible for launching the term ‘catfish’ into the vernacular. We were familiar with the term, of course, but not with the show, which had a different effect on each of us.
We discuss the usual fare – concept and structure, episode highlights, authenticity and appeal – but we delve quite a bit more into our personal takes on the show, particularly in the case of JS, who enjoyed the show for what it was until Mike burst his bubble with an article he found online debunking the show’s authenticity. We also take on some of the larger issues the show focuses on, particularly in terms of what it has to say about social media usage and ‘self-acceptance,’ with the assistance of an interesting academic article we found that analyzes and critiques the show’s messaging.
Show Notes and Links
1:26 / Mike outs himself as the victim of a celebrity podcast catfishing scheme
2:06 / Introducing this month’s show
3:17 / The concept and structure of this show (inspired by a documentary of the same name)
6:37 / Our impressions of the two hosts, Nev and Max
8:07 / Dual roles of hosts – investigation and therapy/counseling
9:23 / The show’s tone ran contrary to JS’s expectations, particularly for an MTV reality show (Our episode on My Super Sweet 16)
12:42 / The order in which each of us watched the episodes and how it affected our viewing
13:43 / Episode 1 – Sunny and Jamison (Chelsea)
14:43 / Episode 3 – Kim and Matt
15:01 / Episode 7 – Joe and Kari Ann (Rose) – Watch this one!
16:58 / Episode 2 – Trina and Scorpio (Lee) and Episode 8 – Tyler and Amanda (Aaron)
17:58 / Episode 4 – Jasmine and Mike (Mhissy)
18:46 / Transitioning to the question of authenticity
21:30 / Our initial impressions of the authenticity and how the article affected our reading of the show (the article we mention and discuss – Is Catfish Catfishing America?)
23:15 / Talking about how much we bought the narrative in Episode 7 (Mike mentions The Truman Show)
26:28 / How genuine are these investigations by Nev and Max? (Kari Ann Peniche’s Wikipedia article)
28:18 / The one moment of authenticity – the catfishee’s reaction to meeting the catfisher – made us feel uncomfortable (Our Maury episode)
31:15 / Finding out how the show was actually constructed undermined its ethical justification, Mike almost would have preferred it embrace the seamy side (He mentions the show Cheaters)
32:58 / How much did the inauthenticity sour us on the show? Could it have been done another way?
34:22 / What JS wanted from the narrative and how finding out the truth made him think it was all done on the catfisher’s terms
35:32 / Mike pushes back a little – thinks it would be easier for the catfisher to not go on TV, thinks the show is done more on the producer’s terms
36:53 / The thing that irritated us most about the show’s ethics was the false front it put up of ‘helping’ people
37:10 / Segueing into the article for this month: Catching a Catfish: Constructing the ‘good’ social media user in reality television, Michael Lovelock, Television & New Media, Vol. 18, Issue 3, March 2017
38:05 / The broad thesis of the article and overview of its main themes
38:54 / What Mike thought was most interesting in the article
40:24 / JS also found the emphasis on self-acceptance as substitute for traditional markers of success interesting
42:04 / Mike liked the analysis of catfishing as being on the continuum of online activity and not apart from it
46:50 / What did we think of the article writer’s contention that reality TV narratives are ideal for constructing ‘good’ social media behavior? (JS mentions the online forum Reddit; Mike mentions Foucault again and our Paris Hilton BFF Dubai episode)
50:24 / Ending on where the appeal of the show lies
52:38 / What specifically in the narrative captured JS’s interest before finding out about the inauthenticity?
54:24 / Mike didn’t enjoy it as much, but that also insulated him from being crestfallen when he discovered the article
55:40 / Mike thinks part of the appeal of this show is due to the inherent uncertainty of online relationships and our fears surrounding them
56:30 / Introducing the show for our next episode (Mike mentions the caravan aka the “terror-van” – remember that? He also confused the presidential and Congressional inauguration dates – you don’t have to email him a correction.)
58:25 / Mike’s half-hearted holiday well-wishes and our plan for the rest of the season